The Ruiz Group

LOCAL MARKET INSIDER

For Monterey County

November 2026

Monterey County Blog

Subscribe to get updated on the most recent information from The Ruiz Group - Monterey County

What a 4.5% Commission Bought One Seaside Seller

October 22, 2026

The appraisal said $550,000. We sold it for $670,000.

The seller was 26 years old, had just inherited the house, and had never owned real estate in her life. Everyone told her to sell it as-is with a discount agent. She paid us 4.5% instead, put $23,000 into prep she did not have in cash, and walked away with about $80,600 more than the as-is plan would have produced.

Here is every number, including what we charged and what it bought.

I am putting our own fee on the page because the fee is the part sellers argue about and the part that gets decided with the least information. If a higher rate cannot show you a bigger net, you should not pay it. On this sale it could.

The house nobody wanted to invest in

Annie's property was a one-bedroom home in Seaside on a tight, one-way street. Not a trophy listing. The kind of house where most of the industry says take the quick sale and move on.

She could not afford that advice. She planned to use the proceeds to buy a home in Arizona outright, in cash. The difference between a good sale and an average one was the difference between owning her next house free and clear or carrying a mortgage into her thirties.

"You're 26," I told her. "I'm assuming this is all you really have." She confirmed it. So we treated the sale that way.

The $23,000 plan

The house needed work, and the work was not glamorous.

  • New paint inside and out.
  • New flooring.
  • Bathroom upgrades.
  • Landscaping.
  • Cosmetic work on the facade.
  • A big crack in the garage floor, filled, sealed, and the whole surface epoxied.

Total: about $23,000. Annie did not have $23,000 sitting in an account, which is where most sellers in her position stop and list as-is.

She chose our Elite package instead, which let our team front the funds for the prep work. She repaid it out of escrow at closing. No loan, no credit card, no money out of pocket while the work was being done.

What the market did with a finished product

Seaside is the tightest segment on the Peninsula right now. The median sale price sits at $805,562, homes are going pending in about 20 days, sale-to-list is 99.6%, and 37.6% of homes sell above asking. Buyers here are active, financing-dependent, and extremely sensitive to condition, because their budgets have no room for a surprise.

Annie's home went live prepped, staged, and priced on comps. We accepted an offer at $680,000. The new appraisal capped the deal at $670,000, so that is where it closed.

Sit with that for a second. A buyer was willing to pay $10,000 more than the appraiser believed the house was worth. That is what presentation does to perceived value.

The full math

Every number, start to finish.

  • Sale price: $670,000. At 4.5%, our commission was $30,150.
  • The as-is comparison: a 2.5% commission on the original $550,000 appraised value would have been $13,750.
  • Difference in commission: $16,400.
  • Plus the prep: $23,000, repaid from escrow.
  • Total additional investment: $39,400.
  • Additional sale price over the original appraisal: $120,000.
  • Annie's net gain over the as-is path: $80,600.

Would you pay an agent an extra $16,400 and invest $23,000 in your home if it netted you an extra $80,600? Annie did, at 26, with no experience, because the math held up when she asked about it.

Where the money actually went

People hear "prep" and picture a remodel. It was not a remodel. Nothing structural changed, no walls moved, no kitchen was ripped out.

Every dollar went to things a buyer sees in the first ninety seconds. Paint decides whether a room feels cared for. Flooring decides whether a buyer trusts the rest of the house. Landscaping and the facade decide whether they walk in wanting to like it. The bathroom was the one room where a small budget changes the whole impression of the home, so that is where the upgrade money went.

The garage crack is the detail I point to most. A filled, sealed, epoxied garage floor costs very little and takes one problem completely off the table. Left alone, a crack in a slab makes buyers think foundation, and once that word enters a buyer's head you are negotiating against a fear rather than a fact.

That is the whole logic of prep. You are not improving the house for yourself. You are removing every reason a buyer could give themselves to offer less.

What this looks like for a Seaside seller today

Seaside buyers are financing-dependent, which changes the job. Their lender orders an appraisal, their inspector reads every report, and their budget has no slack for deferred maintenance. A home that shows clean and inspects clean moves through escrow. A home that does not gets renegotiated at day 15.

So the prep list here is practical rather than decorative: inspections first, then the visible items, then staging. Do it in that order and you get both the price and the smooth close. Do it backwards and you are staging a house that a buyer's inspector is about to reprice.

Why the fee is the wrong thing to shop

The amount you pay an agent has nothing to do with what you get for your investment. Those are two separate questions, and most sellers only ask the first one.

Agents who lead with a discount are usually leading with the only thing they have. A lower rate is not a strategy for selling your house. It is a strategy for getting your listing.

Ask yourself the obvious follow-up: if they give away their own money that quickly, how hard will they fight for yours in a negotiation? I have watched a discount agent talk a seller into a five-figure credit request in escrow rather than spend an afternoon arguing the point.

The phrase "industry standard" is not a real thing either. It is what agents say when they cannot justify their compensation with actual math.

How the tiers actually work

At TRG we run three service packages: Basic at 2.5%, Advanced at 3.5%, and Elite at 4.5%.

Which one fits is not a preference. It comes out of a formula that weighs your circumstances against your property. On your side: time, available capital, how involved you can be, what else is happening in your life. On the property side: condition, deferred maintenance, cosmetic needs, staging requirements.

A well-maintained home owned by someone with time and cash may need very little from us beyond strategy and execution, and Basic covers it. A dated property owned by someone across the country who cannot manage contractors needs the whole machine, and that is Elite. Annie was the second case with a twist: she was local and engaged, but she had no capital.

The thing every tier has in common is the outcome we are aiming at: the most money, in the shortest time, with the least hassle. The package only changes who does what and who fronts what.

Coachable is not passive

What made Annie a great client was not that she did whatever we said.

She asked pointed questions about every recommendation: why this, why now, what does it do to the number. After each explanation she would say, "Okay, I understand that. That makes complete sense." Then she moved.

There is a wide middle ground between a seller who fights their agent on every decision and a seller who checks out entirely. Annie lived in that middle, and it is the best place to be. She understood the plan, so she was not spooked when the work took time or when the first week on market was quiet.

That is what Prep. Price. Present.™ needs from a seller. Not obedience, just a willingness to look at the math.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it expensive to live in Seaside, CA?

Seaside is the most attainable coastal city on the Monterey Peninsula, with a median sale price of $805,562 compared with a Monterey County median of $879,556 and much higher figures in Pacific Grove and Carmel. Demand is strong, with 37.6% of homes selling above asking.

Are real estate commissions negotiable in California?

Yes. Commission rates are set by agreement between you and your broker, not by law or by any standard rate. What matters is what the fee buys: strategy, prep, staging, media, negotiation, and how those translate into your net.

Is a higher commission ever worth it?

It is worth it when the extra service produces more than it costs. Annie paid $16,400 above a discount rate plus $23,000 in prep, and the home sold $120,000 above its original appraised value. Ask any agent to show you that arithmetic on your own property before you decide.

Can my agent pay for repairs before I list?

In our Elite package, yes. We front the cost of prep work and get repaid out of escrow at closing. That is how sellers with no available cash still get a fully prepped home on the market.

What happens if the appraisal comes in below the offer?

The loan is based on the appraised value, so the buyer either brings the difference in cash, renegotiates, or walks. Annie's buyer offered $680,000 and the appraisal capped the sale at $670,000. Strong prep and real comps are what keep that gap small.

How much can prep add to a sale price?

It varies by property, and the pattern is consistent. The National Association of REALTORS® reports that 83% of buyers' agents say staging helps clients picture a home as their own, and 49% of sellers' agents say it shortened time on market. On Annie's house, $23,000 of prep helped produce $120,000 over the original appraisal.

The Bottom Line

Judge an agent by what you net, not by what they charge.

A 26-year-old with no experience and no cash for repairs beat the standard advice by $80,600 because she looked at the numbers instead of the rate. Ask for the same math on your house, from every agent you interview, and pick the one whose plan holds up.

Grab your custom prep plan with our 2-minute assessment.

See which service tier fits your Seaside home, what prep it needs, and what you could net after every cost, based on Pete's Prep. Price. Present.™ methodology.

Related Reading

References

  1. Redfin, Seaside Housing Market. redfin.com/city/18079/CA/Seaside/housing-market
  2. Redfin, Monterey County Housing Market. redfin.com/county/329/CA/Monterey-County/housing-market
  3. National Association of REALTORS®, 2025 Profile of Home Staging. nar.realtor/research-and-statistics/research-reports/profile-of-home-staging
Back to Blog

Let's Connect

Book Your One-on-One
Strategy Session

Whether you're thinking about buying, selling, or building wealth through real estate — a personalized strategy session is the best place to start. No pressure. Just clarity.

  • Address

    29251 Highway 1, Carmel, CA 93923

Monterey County • Silicon Valley

© 2026 The Ruiz Group. All rights reserved.

Terms of Services | Privacy Policy

The Ruiz Group of Keller Williams Realty

Team Leader: Pete Ruiz | DRE #01974535

Managing Broker: Dan Hill | DRE #01350268